Saturday, 17 October 2026

William Tyndale the Protestant martyr

 

9:00  Chris Howard does not seem to understand that under SK, belief is optional ie neither forbidden nor compulsory.

SK would not forbid praying ie personal interaction with a Higher Power.

11:00  Prayer concentrates the mind if nothing else. 

12:00  The reason for my agnosticism

13:00  Atheists are always wishing for things ie praying.

14:00  "God if you exist ... "

15:00  Our relationship with God

16:00  Stoicism

18:00  Fighting for our principles

19:00  Rules and boundaries


21:00  People are afraid of being understood. 

22:00  Organised religion and the afterlife

23:00  Papal Conclave forever

24:00  Decisive moral action

25:00  Teacher: "What did I just say?"

26:00  Steel man and straw man

27:00  It is the mark of an educated man to be able to entertain an idea without accepting it. 

Morality

28:00  Holding our rulers to account without knowing the rules is impossible.  

29:00  George Washington farewell speech

30:00  Mandatory, Advisory, Discretionary

31:00  Monarchy v Republic

32:00  William Tyndale

34:00  Marginal notes

35:00  Constantine the Great

36:00  Church to "congregation"

37:00  Priest to "elder/senior",  charity to "love", penance to "repentance"

Baptist

39:00  Baptists not Protestants?  

40:00  Northern and Southern Baptists and the American Civil War

41:00  Jefferson Bible

The confirmation ceremony did not start as a separate event; it originated in the early Church (1st to 3rd centuries) as part of a single, unified rite of Christian initiation (Baptism, anointing/laying on of hands, and the Eucharist) performed together for adult converts. [1, 2]
Catholic Church
  • Unified Beginning (1st–4th Century): In the early centuries, baptism, the laying on of hands (the root of confirmation), and first communion were given all at once during the Easter Vigil by the bishop. [1, 2]
  • Separation (5th–6th Century): As Christianity spread to rural areas and infant baptism became common, local bishops could no longer attend every baptism. To preserve the bishop’s role in completing initiation, the anointing and laying on of hands were delayed and became a separate ceremony. [1]
  • Term and Codification: The term confirmatio appeared by the mid-5th century (used by figures like Leo the Great and Faustus of Riez), and it evolved through the Middle Ages into a distinct sacrament of the Latin (Roman Catholic) Church. [1, 2, 3]
Anglican Church (Church of England)
  • Reformation Continuity and Adaptation (16th Century): The Anglican Church inherited the practice from the Western Catholic tradition. During the English Reformation, Anglicanism demoted confirmation from its status as a strict gospel sacrament (classifying it instead as a "lesser" or pastoral rite), while retaining the historic order of bishops and the laying on of hands. [1, 2, 3]
  • Evolution: The Church of England established its own distinct liturgical framework for confirmation in the early Book of Common Prayer, transforming it into a moment for baptized individuals (often adolescents) to publicly confirm their baptismal vows after catechism. [1, 2, 3]
48:00  None of Chris's children baptised.

53:00  Catholicism in America

54:00  Rhode Island

Catholic woman admits she is a nihilist


So morality is just an emotion?

1:00  Is Megan admitting to nihilism?

1:00  No example given, no example asked.

2:00  So you're basically saying you have no convictions?

2:45  Can you give an example of what is sustainable regardless of morality?  Are you basically admitting that you are a nihilist?

3:00  You can only be righteous if you have principles. What are your principles? If you're saying your principles are Catholic principles, what are Catholic principles? If you're saying your principles have nothing to do with Catholicism, are you in fact admitting that you are a nihilist who has no principles because you are not sure about anything and are suspicious of people who have moral convictions? Do you know what a moral conviction is? If there is no answer, I will assume that you have none, making you a nihilist, as I suspected all along. All people claiming to be Christians do not really worship the Trinity. So why do they claim to be  Christian? It is just the Religion of Mum and Dad. Why would anyone pretend to be Christian if they don't have Christian beliefs and don't care to discuss the Trinity? Is it because they think it is too hot a topic to discuss or because they are actually bored by the whole thing? 

3:00  What is "it"?

The most common term for someone who doubts everything is a *skeptic* (or *sceptic* in British English), defined as a person who habitually doubts accepted beliefs and requires evidence before accepting truth.

Other specific terms depend on the nature of the doubt:
*   **Doubting Thomas**: Someone who refuses to believe anything until they see physical proof themselves.
*   **Cynic**: Someone who is skeptical of human sincerity and generally distrusts others' motives.
*   **Pyrrhonian**: A pedantic term for a skeptic who doubts everything, including the possibility of knowing any truth.
*   **Denialist**: A person who rejects established facts or evidence despite strong proof to the contrary.

Is this what you are confessing to, Megan - Are you basically saying that you have no moral convictions?

Interestingly, none of the Seven Dwarves raised an eyebrow.

45:00  CLAIRE KHAW joins. What is "it"?
46:00  EU referendum
47:00  Was Christianity it?
48:00  Being American is the stronger identity for Megan and her associates, isn't it?
47:00  Principles are to die for.

59:00  Brett talks about what it means to believe.

1:01:00  Freudian Theory

1:03:00  Flow state

1:04:00  Mega is just not feeling it. 

1:05:00  It should be a pleasure to do our duty. 

1:07:00  Questioning our own motives

Adan and Eve

1:08:00  Jesus wouldn't do a thing  like this. 

1:09:00  Satan is sent to tempt us into disobedience. 

1:10:00  Minimum standards

100% and pass mark

1:11:00  Mortal sins

1:12:00  Christian Universalism or eternal damnation for all Christians who die guilty of idolatry and blasphemy.

Thursday, 15 October 2026

Khalid Safir on the Cornell 7, no fault divorce, the sarco pod and the loss of social skills


1:00  Sex, marriage and romance
2:00  Cornell 7
3:00  Single sex universities
4:00  Reckless endangerment


7:00  Crime and punishment
8:00  Post coital withdrawal of consent
9:00  The Islamic answer  to Western social problems
11:00  Pregnant schoolgirls

Suicide pods

13:00  Being ghosted
14:00  Plenty of fish in the sea
Shared memories
15:00  "Cheers - where everyone knows your name"
Avatar
Smart People
16:00  Social skills and emotional intelligence
18:00  How are the mighty fallen
Wisdom > cunning

19:00  Evil/insane/stupid

20:00  The Aztec Empire

Ancient Egyptians

21:00  The Sword of Damocles

22:00  Declining empires

23:00  Sex in the animal kingdom

24:00  Marriage 

25:00  Random raping

26:00  Transgender women

28:00  Why women have to choose

29:00  Forced marriages

30:00  The Romantic Movement

Asking for the father for his daughter's hand in marriage

31:00  Women must have the right to choose their spouse. 

33:00  Fornication forbidden

Cornell 7

34:00  Fathers know how men think.

36:00  Attractive men also end up on the shelf.

Monogamy

37:00  Fornication

Prostituton

38:00  Bad women are for bad men. 

Abolition of no fault divorce

40:00  Is no fault divorce Islamic?

41:00  Waiting period

43:00  Wife-beating verse 

45:00  Healthy African birth rate

47:00  Paul Vanderklay

48:00  Food stamps

SK USA

49:00  The Founding Father

50:00  Salem Witch Trials

51:00  Monogamy

53:00  Full marks or pass mark

54:00  Electronic communication  v social interaction

55:00  Large lump sum payment

56:00  50/50 fault

Better the devil you know.

58:00  Suicide rate is lower in married people. 

59:00  Domesticity

1:00:00  If we are murdered, we are more likely to be murdered our spouse - opportunity and proximity. 

Wednesday, 14 October 2026

Joseph Albo separated the core beliefs of Judaism from peripheral ones




**Joseph Albo**, a key Jewish delegate at the **Disputation of Tortosa (1413–1414)**, formulated the three root principles of Judaism in his work *Sefer ha-Ikkarim*, which was written following the disputation. These three fundamental beliefs, which he argued are necessary for divine law to exist, are:

*   **Belief in the existence of God**
*   **Belief in revelation** (that the Torah is the word of God)
*   **Belief in divine retribution** (which includes the immortality of the soul)

While Albo participated in the disputation against the Christian convert **Geronimo de Santa Fe**, his specific formulation of these three roots and their derivative "branches" was developed to define the essential dogmas of Judaism distinct from other faiths.

To clarify the terminology from my previous answer, Joseph Albo's system in *Sefer ha-Ikkarim* actually has **three** hierarchical levels, like a tree:

## The 8 Derivative Principles (*Shorashim*)

These are logically necessary consequences of the three roots. Denying any of them constitutes **heresy**:


 
## The 6 Branches (*Anafim*)

These are obligatory dogmas of **lesser** status — denying them is a **sin**, not heresy, since the "tree" of Judaism can stand without them:

1. Creation *ex nihilo*
2. The supremacy of Moses' prophecy
3. The immutability of the Torah
4. The possibility of attaining human perfection through the performance of a single commandment
5. The resurrection of the dead
6. The coming of the Messiah

So the key distinction: the *shorashim* are indispensable to the existence of divine law itself, while the *anafim* are particular to Judaism specifically but can be "pruned" without destroying the trunk.

Antisemitism is evidence of atheism or incorrect belief in God


Pleonasms

2:00  Antisemitism included Arabs because of their rejection of the Trinity. 

3:00  Christianity is a hold-all for White Supremacy.

Jews are required to accept converts.s 

4:00  Antisemitism is evidence of atheism or incorrect belief in God. 

Isaiah 45:7 and Job

6:00  Jews are the eternal fall guy/stooge of gentiles.

8:00  Jew blaming is the sacred narrative of antisemites.

9:00  Atheism is the idolatry of atheists worshiping their own dumb opinions who are also hypocrites hoping to benefit from the status of the religious group they claim to be a member of. 

11:00  The utility and logic of the Abrahamic God

12:00  Principled leadership required.

13:00  The purpose of our life is to display our moral agency that we have because of our free will. Using our moral reasoning, we are supposed to show that we are capable knowing the difference between good and evil in theory and in practice once we understand the terms of the divine bargain between God and Man. 

Mortal sin

14:00  Blasphemy is a mortal sin. 

15:00  Human history is linear. 

16:00  Hypocrites should blame themselves. 

17:00  Lurve

19:00  Polytheism is always defeated by Ockham's Razor.

22:00  Polytheism is anthropomorphism.

Splash pregnancy

23:00  Unfalsifiable premises

24:00  Scientists and ethical monotheists agree about the Creation.

26:00  Righteous and unrighteous indviduals

27:00  Panderers panderer

28:00  Three kinds of Trinitarians

29:00  Were any of the Founding Fathers Catholic?

AI Overview

**Yes, several of the Founding Fathers were Catholic.** **Charles Carroll of Carrollton** was the only Catholic to sign the Declaration of Independence, while **Daniel Carroll** and **Thomas Fitzsimons** were the only two Catholics to sign the United States Constitution.

*   **Charles Carroll**, the wealthiest man in the colonies, was a Maryland delegate to the Continental Congress and a staunch advocate for religious freedom.
*   **Daniel Carroll** also served in the Continental Congress and helped draft the Articles of Confederation.
*   **Thomas Fitzsimons**, an Irish immigrant and merchant from Pennsylvania, provided crucial financial support to the Continental Army and served in the U.S. House of Representatives.
*   **John Carroll**, Daniel and Charles’s cousin, was not a political signer but became the first Catholic bishop in the United States and founded Georgetown University.

Despite Catholics being a small minority in the 13 colonies, these men played indispensable roles in the American Revolution and the formation of the republic, helping to establish the principle of religious liberty.

30:00  Confused Christians

32:00  Christendom

33:00  Christian Anarchism, Christian Universalism, Christian Astrology

34:00  How boomers think

"My boomer dad" 

35:00  What boomers could be doing

36:00  What PVK dares not discuss


37:00  George Washington's farewell speech

38:00  Conspiracy theories

40:00  Belief in God is a conspiracy theory. 

... and you're going to hell.


"Superstition is transactional" - What does this even mean?


I am not primarily a YouTuber.


2:00  Superstition can easily be distinguished from ethical monotheism. 

3:00  Heresy is wrongthink.

4:00  The Deadly Sin of Heaven

5:00  Nathan and Shari locked horns.

6:00  The difference between religion and superstition

7:00  Giving up our wrongthink

8:00  Ron Copperman is a heretical Jew. 

9:00  A Nazi who loves Jews

11:00  Shari's comment

12:00  Status

Anglophobia

13:00  Shari told the men there is no difference between thriving and surviving and no one contradicted her.

14:00  Mark S

16:00  Mark Parker

17:00  Mark Parker doesn't feel that he needs to believe in the Trinity or  the Bible stories he doesn't agree with and still be Christian. 

19:00  Tertullian: "We believe in it because it is absurd." 

20:00  Ethical monotheists are supposed to believe that all good and evil come from God.

21:00  Atheism is harmful because narcissistic nihilists and atheists suffering from the Deadly Sin of Pride who worship their own opinions will be so intellectually dishonest they won't concede a point even when they cannot argue against it.

Do heretical Christians afraid of offending each other deserve Christian fellowship?

 

1:00  Christians are like the Roman Empire: Romans were people who hated kings who became people who worshiped their deceased emperors; Christianity was an organised religion but is now more like the leaderless hippie movement.

3:00  I am like Rosa Parks.
4:00  Christianity used to be an organised religion.

5:00  Should ex-Christians who still want to worship God choose Islam or the Noahide laws? American Christians should choose the religion of the holy book that gave them their First Amendment.

AI Overview

In his famous 1734 English translation of the Quran, the British Orientalist George Sale translated the opening of Surah Al-Baqarah (2:256) as:
"Let there be no violence in religion." [1]
While modern English translations typically render Lā ikrāha fī ad-dīn as "There is no compulsion in religion," Sale chose the word "violence" to convey the prohibition of forcing a faith upon someone. [1, 2]
Sale's Explanatory Notes & Commentary
In his extensive accompanying footnotes and his Preliminary Discourse, Sale elaborated on the context of tolerance and religious freedom regarding this verse:
  • No Forced Conversions: Sale noted that this verse explicitly establishes that people should not be violently forced to accept Islam. He regularly highlighted in his commentary that the Prophet Muhammad protected the "People of the Book" (Jews and Christians) in exchange for a tribute (jizyah) rather than forcing them to convert. [1, 2, 3]
  • Safe Passage and Choice: Commenting on the broader Quranic application of this principle (such as treating captives or enemy emissaries), Sale explained that if individuals chose not to accept the religion, Muslims were obligated to grant them safe conduct back to their place of origin where they were secure. [1]
  • Rejection of the "Sword" Myth: Sale famously challenged prevailing 18th-century Western biases regarding the spread of Islam. He noted that claiming Islam spread purely by the sword was an oversimplification and an allegation, pointing out that in many countries, the sword was never used, and the religion spread peacefully. [1, 2]
6:00  The Trinity can only be "defended" with violence.

7:00  A Christian Amendment would be supremely unAmerican. 

8:00  Orthodox Christianity is popular with anti-Zionist White Nationalists because the Orthodox Church has never recognised Israel. 

9:00  Neoconservatism = American imperialism

10:00  A trash bag of rotting elephant meat

11:00  Do heretical Christians afraid of offending each other deserve Christian fellowship?

12:00  Three kinds of Trinitarian Christian: Cultural Christians who deny the Trinity and perhaps God; Believing Christians who worship the Trinity; Christian Nationalists who want their country back

14:00  A gang of pirates, bandits, gangsters, idolaters, blasphemers, lunatics, liars and sex offenders
15:00  Atheists and nihilists
16:00  Islamophobic bachelors
17:00  Bear Hat Man whom I thought was a Muslim called Danjuma
19:00  Leibniz
21:00  Noah's Ark apparently found in Turkey.
22:00  Shroud of Turin
23:00  13 Principles of Judaism
24:00  Christian hypocrites are really nihilists. 
25:00  TLC are Christian heretics spreading heresy.
26:00  Ron Copperman the self-appointed priest of TLC
28:00  Prayer couched in moral and sound arguments
29:00  Nathan is both atheist and Christian.
30:00  Doug Wilson
31:00  Stupider and stupider
Who is a true Christian?
32:00  Mark Parker
33:00  Christianity is a bag full of leaks.
34:00  Christianity has failed to defend monarchy. 
35:00  Not all Pentecostalists are Trinitarian. 
38:00  Divided Muslims
43:00  "Your arm has fallen off."

God does not change the lot of those who do not change what is in their hearts. 

45:00  How many more Amendments to the US constitution?

France is on its Fifth Republic

46:00  What are the rules?

47:00  Doctrine of Parliamentary Supremacy

48:00  Western civilisation as we know it is coming to an end. 

50:00  Western civilisation is dying of feminism, atheism and nihilism.

William Tyndale the Protestant martyr

  9:00  Chris Howard does not seem to understand that under SK, belief is optional ie neither forbidden nor compulsory. SK would not forbid ...