Rabbi Tatz does not answer my questions

Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks with Tal Keinan on the Jewish future

What an unnecessarily long-winded introduction by this woman whom I believe is not quite modestly dressed because we can see her knees. I don't think she is wearing a wig either because he hair looks natural.



Z888:
Why would you put her down?  Her skirt may be too short for your religious orthodox requirements due to her sitting down her skirt may have risen up above the knee especially when wearing leg stockings however, she did an amazing job interviewing both guests.  You should always give credit when credit is due.  For a young lady she clearly did her best to represent her community in the best light possible.  Well done.



Claire Khaw:
@Z888 "Young lady?" She is a wife and a mother and, apparently, a female Rosh Kehilla of the Downtown Minyan. Her husband is a rabbi! Why on heart is he not moderating this discussion? I am sure he wouldn't be wearing a too-short frock however pretty causing controversy with his knees and making us all scratch our heads about what on earth she meant about the Rivers Mississippi and Colorado!

https://countryeconomy.com/countries/usa-states/compare/mississippi/colorado

Mijal Bitton
https://hartman.org.il/Faculty_View.asp?faculty_id=232&Cat_Id=333&Cat_Type=about

The Downtown Minyan of which she is Rosh Kehilla is very liberal indeed, as you can tell from https://www.thedowntownminyan.com/the-team

Poor Rabbi Sacks is completely outnumbered and outgunned at this discussion: on the one hand there is this rebbetzin who doesn't see fit to mention that she is rebbetzin, on the other there is the global financier who seems to be saying that the Torah cannot quite keep up with the modern world.  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tal_Keinan


14:00  God created gentiles to appreciate Judaism, says Rabbi Sacks. I think God chose Jews because He had to choose someone.  https://radicalisedrabbi.blogspot.com/2019/01/why-jews-are-gods-chosen-people-and-my.html

15:00  You can't be God's Chosen People. If gentiles all became Jewish, Jews wouldn't feel special or chosen any more. You were however created to be the light of the nations and enforce the Noahide laws on the gentiles. That much is clear. How about doing more of this sort of thing instead of being liberal and assimilated, which is not what you are supposed to do anyway since you are supposed to keep yourselves apart as your religion requires?

https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/the-noahide-laws/

The late Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, the last leader of Chabad-Lubavitch Hasidism. Schneerson wrote:

We must do everything possible to ensure that the seven Noahide laws are observed. If this can be accomplished through force or through other kinder and more peaceful means through explaining to non-Jews that they should accept God’s wishes [we should do so]…Anyone who is able to influence a non-Jew in any way to keep the seven commandments is obligated to do so, since that is what God commanded Moses our teacher (“Sheva Mitzvot Shel Benai Noach,” Hapardes 59:9 7-11, 5745)

37:00  OMG. How short is her skirt now?

38:00  Should non-Orthodox ie non-observant Jews be considered Jews at all?

My brilliant solution to antisemitism: a Registrar and Register of Jews

http://thevoiceofreason-ann.blogspot.com/2018/11/the-pittsburgh-massacre-why-is-anti.html

43:00  Rabbi Sacks: "We may have choose our individual routes, but let's have a shared destination." Where might this shared destination be? Is Rabbi Sacks saying Jews should all go to Israel?

47:00  Is Rabbi Sacks proposing the reintroduction of Herem for unethical Jewish businessmen like what they did to Baruch Spinoza, Leon Trotsky and Grigory Zinoviev?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herem_(censure)

Alain de Botton's short video on the pantheism of Spinoza and why he was censured.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pVEeXjPiw54


55:00  Secular Jews make up the numbers for the State of Israel, says Rabbi Sacks, but is that the idea? If you are meant to be a kingdom of priests, then you must be a theocracy with secular Jews not already stoned outside the city gates for breaking the Sabbath allowed only as a very insignificant and marginalised group. I imagine Tal Keinan won't like hearing this.

https://biblehub.com/exodus/19-6.htm

My brilliant solution to antisemitism: a Registrar and Register of Jews

IF JEWS DID NOT EXIST, THEY WOULD HAVE TO BE INVENTED

If Jews did not exist, they would have to be invented. The Jews of China during the time of the Cultural Revolution were of course the wealthy, the landlords, the business owners and university professors.

Jews are now synonymous and conflated with the liberal elite who want to sabotage Brexit and continue with neoliberalism, borderless nations and neocon foreign policy.

ANTISEMITISM WILL CONTINUE TO EXIST AS LONG AS THE GENTILE IS CAPABLE OF THE DEADLY SINS OF ENVY, ANGER, PRIDE AND SLOTH AS WELL AS SCAPEGOATING

There will never be an end to antisemitism as long as the gentile is capable of envy. The Reform Jew is as stupid as the Liberal Gentile. Of course Jews will be hated for as long as the gentile is capable of the deadly sins of pride, anger, envy and sloth. The lower he sinks, the more he will hate the Jew, and he is sinking fast into the moral sewage that came with the disease of feminism that he is now nearly up to his neck.

MUSLIMS REPRESENT THE IMMIGRATION THE WESTERN GENTILE HATES AND FEARS

The Western gentile hates Muslims because Muslims are totemic of his hatred of the immigrants who have come to his land, but he especially hates Muslims because they are so numerous and visible and now look upon him with undisguised contempt.

JEWS REPRESENT THE POLITICAL CLASSES THE WESTERN GENTILE DESPISES AND DISTRUSTS

The Jew represents to the antisemite his political classes who clearly care nothing for him.  He thinks his politicians are either following orders from Jews or so stupid that they they do not know they are doing the bidding of Jews.

WHY JEWS KEEP GETTING THE BLAME WHEN IT IS FEMINISM THAT CAUSES IMMIGRATION AND PAEDOPHILIA

The problem is feminism but the antisemitic Islamophobe is too cowardly, lazy and intellectually dishonest to admit this because, however promiscuous and immoral his women, he will perceive them to be at least useful in that they represent potential sex partners for him, while the Jews and Muslims he hates do not. For this reason he would rather blame feminism, pornography and the failure of his religion and political system on Jews too.

MY PROPOSED REGISTRAR AND REGISTER OF JEWS FOR THE QUALITY CONTROL OF JEWISH TRIBAL MEMBERSHIP

May I ask Rabbi Bar-Hayim why the measures of herem are not longer used on Jews who commit Chillul Hashem? How about a National Register and Registrar of Jews in each country to keep members of the tribe in order? If they have broken the Sabbath, I am not suggesting that they be stoned, but they could certainly be struck off the Register by their rabbi so that as a non-Jew they escape the death penalty.

KAPUT CHRISTIANITY IS OBVIOUSLY IDOLATROUS SO THIS MEANS JEWS MUST ENCOURAGE WESTERNERS TO ADOPT ISLAM BECAUSE THEY MUST HAVE A RELIGION OR THEIR DEGENERACY WILL JUST DEEPEN AND ACCELERATE UNTIL THEY BECOME A FAILED STATE AND TAKE IT OUT ON JEWS

God if He created us clearly intended there to be Jews and gentiles. Judaism is for Jews only, and Islam for gentiles.

DIVINE ETHNO NATIONALISM, DIVINE CIVIC NATIONALISM

If Judaism is divine ethno-nationalism, then Islam must be divine civic nationalism.

Islam is the only religion capable of regenerating the degenerate West anyway, since Christianity is kaput.

THE IDOLATROUS DOCTRINE OF THE TRINITY THAT NO ONE REALLY BELIEVES IN, EXPLAINING WHY HYPOCRISY AND CHRISTIANITY GO HAND IN HAND

Not only is Christianity kaput, its absurd Doctrine of the Trinity is undeniably idolatrous. The doctrine is so absurd that these days most ignorant Post-Christians have no idea they are supposed to believe in this nonsense if they want to be properly Christian, and would reject it when told.

It is quite obvious which of the two Abrahamic faiths for gentiles is more in conformity with the Noahide laws and it isn't Christianity.

Perhaps Rabbi Bar-Hayim would like to pronounce on this.

ISLAM IS THE BEST FIT TO DO JUSTICE TO WOMEN AND MINORITIES, WITH JEWS BEING GIVEN A PRIVILEGED STATUS AS LONG AS THEY FULFIL THEIR DUTY TO THE GENTILE BY REMINDING HIM WHEN HIS LAWS FALL BELOW THE MINIMUM MORAL STANDARDS OF THE NOAHIDE LAWS EG WHEN HE STARTS PROMOTING - HORROR OF HORRORS AND ABOMINATION OF ABOMINATIONS - GLOBAL GAY MARRIAGE

Islam is after all the only religion that allows the gentile to be fair to his women (without being undermined by Cultural Marxism AKA Feminism) and minorities with Jews having a privileged status of being People of the Book. Muslims cannot after all deny that Islam is built on the foundations of Judaism and Christianity.

Once the West decides to adopt Islam at the suggestion of Jews and has returned to good moral order, the danger of pogrom-inclined antisemitism will abate.

 If every gentile became a Jew, then Jews would no longer be God's Chosen People, would they? Judaism is an exclusive club and not for everyone. Islam is a more a political party in a one party state.

"In view of the strict monotheism of Islam, Muslims were considered as Noachides whereas the status of Christians was a matter of debate" is from a Jewish source at https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/the-seven-noachide-laws

THE MORAL AND RELIGIOUS OBLIGATION OF THE JEW TO GENTILE WHICH HE MUST START PERFORMING PRONTO

I am afraid I have to remind you that Jews also have a duty to impose the Noahide laws on the gentile.

Rabbi Schneerson:

"We must do everything possible to ensure that the seven Noahide laws are observed. If this can be accomplished through force or through other kinder and more peaceful means through explaining to non-Jews that they should accept God’s wishes [we should do so]…Anyone who is able to influence a non-Jew in any way to keep the seven commandments is obligated to do so, since that is what God commanded Moses our teacher" (“Sheva Mitzvot Shel Benai Noach,” Hapardes 59:9 7-11, 5745)

https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/the-noahide-laws

USURY

Islam already gives a special status to the People of the Book and acknowledges that it was built on the foundations of Judaism and Islam. It acknowledges all the prophets of the Bible including the Virgin Birth. Even better, Islam bans usury, which means it will stop both Jew and gentile individuals and governments from getting into trouble ever again over the irresponsible lending and borrowing caused by usury. The gentile had a terrible habit of borrowing money from Jews under usurious terms and then expelling them from their country when they knew they could no longer repay their debt.

You do not seem to have noticed that economic policy neoliberalism and its progressive ie sexually liberated views backed by the military force of neoconservatism is also a quasi-religion which is globally implemented.

JEWS CAN ONLY BE THE LIGHT OF THE NATIONS IF THEY SPEAK TRUTH TO LIBTARDS AND TELL THEM RIGHT OFF

Jews will be looked on as the light of the nations when and if they are perceived to have done something useful for gentiles, instead of being perceived to be the creators and proponents of neoconservatism.

Prominent U.S. Jews, Israel Blamed for Start of Iraq War

https://www.haaretz.com/1.4683322

White Man's Burden

The war in Iraq was conceived by 25 neoconservative intellectuals, most of them Jewish, who are pushing President Bush to change the course of history.

https://www.haaretz.com/1.4764706

I only mention the Koran's acceptance of the Virgin Birth as conclusive evidence of Islam being prepared to meet Christians half way. Not for a moment was I suggesting that you should believe in it!  A Virgin Birth is in theory possible, after all.  https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/11894571/Rise-of-the-virgin-birth-four-IVF-clinics-admit-taking-on-such-cases.html

JEWS HAVE A DUTY TO TELL THE GENTILE THAT HIS DEGENERACY IS ACUTE AND CAN ONLY BE REVERSED BY ADOPTING SECULAR KORANISM

Nothing is guaranteed, but Islam offers a better chance of moral regeneration for the West than continuing with its current satanic rotten modern culture with the abomination of abominations, gay marriage!  If moral regeneration is achieved and the patriarchy restored, then Jew and gentile will enjoy small good rational government again. If we continue marinating in its current moral sewage, things will get worse for both Jew and gentile until the West is nothing but a series of failed states falling like dominoes to chaos, disorder, war and revolution.